Despite the appearance of a very few proto-buds on the local trees and 50˚ temperatures earlier in the week, winter's not ready to quit yet—not in New England. It's been just above or below freezing for the past few days, and according to the forecast we'll be ball-and-chained to our wool coats for at least the next ten.
"But today marks the 3rd anniversary of the invasion of Iraq!" you say.
Exactly. And that's why I began this post by talking about the weather. Because what I really want to talk about is Jorie Graham's reading in Cambridge on Tuesday evening.
Simultaneity she called it—the bloody war overseas and the slow approach of spring. How do we accommodate both our very human desire to enjoy the earth's renewal and our grief over the human tragedy unfolding around us? For myself, how do I joyfully look forward to entering the institution of marriage while so many same-sex couples are barred from the doing the same? This is what it's like to be a person in our times. These are our confusions.
One of the most important things we can do is pay attention, she suggested. Witness. The mainstream media isn't reporting the half of it. Not the war; not government spying. Keep your books. When they dig it all up ages hence, our books will give them some sense of who we were. Those who disagree with Graham's politics might have called her opening remarks a rant, but I found them incredibly refreshing. It was invigorating to hear a poet whose work I admire engaging the issues that matter so deeply to me.
That's why, her alleged difficulty aside, I called Overlord a Sincere book several months back. In poem after poem, Graham is out of the cloister and in the world, fully present with both mind and heart. The first poem she read was "PRAYING (Attempt of June 6 '03)" [excerpt below in the extended post]. The transition from page to voice, for this reader/listener, was nearly seamless. She spoke the voice I'd mentally heard reading the book—a voice highly charged, and highly invested.
Regarding difficulty, she remarked that academics are the only ones who seem to have any trouble with it. Those who let the logic of the poems wash over them like the logic of daydreams do just fine. Intuition, I'd call it—a method which does not readily lend itself to pseudo-scientific examination and explication. That's not to say Graham is somehow less in control than her more scrutable contemporaries. Not at all. What it means is that she's thinking and writing on a different plane, one that's entirely accessible if we just relax and go with it. I'm sure I'm preaching to the choir for the most part here...
In addition to the poems from Overlord, Graham read a number of new poems by which I was equally impressed. In fact, the only thing that bothered me about the reading was not having the opportunity to express my enthusiasm. I wanted to shout Yes! or clap or do something between poems, but the audience was so sedate I would have accomplished little more than calling undue attention to myself. So I sat there quietly with the rest of the (mostly older) crowd, and waited until after the reading to humiliate myself.
Yes, I got on line to have my book signed and yes, I was probably too effusive in my admiration. What does one say in under 30 seconds to a writer whose book has struck a very deep chord with one's self. Damned if I know.
It's a shame any of us should feel awkward about expressing appreciation for another.
_______________________________________________
The following excerpt requires some contextualization. The voices in the
hedgerows are of D-Day soldiers. During the summer, Graham lives near
the beaches on which the invasion of Normandy took place. The cat is a
stray she found in the hedgerows, who has AIDS and is beginning to
decline. She's obsessively scratching the floor as though trying to
cover feces that aren't there:
... There are people who need ammunition right now or it will be
too late.
There are people
whose names are being typed onto paper right now. One is on his
hands and knees and cannot find his voice to say please, for which
he might be killed. There is the category of by mistake for just about
everything especially death. There are people who need a driver's license or they
shall not
stay in the country. There are people who if the rent is not paid this month
shall not stay in the country. There are people who if they take something
which their child needs, or does not need, which they shall not have the
money for
shall not stay in the country. A country: I beg You, it is not Your dawn yet
here, tell me
what that is. I cannot make out what borders are. What they express is not clear
to me. Why we needed to cut it up like this. No,
it is not clear. From the hedgerows outside some are still audible.
Every morning like this with the mists on them the wide
impassable hedgerows speaking. I turn the news on only to cover it. To cover
the cat's claws scratching the floor I have now cleaned again. To show her it is
clean. "Clean" I say stroking and pointing. Above or below us it must be all right—
is it just
in our stratum? We have tried to cover it with volume, it is still space. We have
covered it with history, it is still a murder and a forgetting. The dead are still
mixed in with the living. Maybe by mistake. Whose? The battle lines
are setting in. Everyone is in his or her hole or should be. Wherever you have
fallen, stay. Distance is your friend, covet it. Even from God, I think, for
now. Your god might be the wrong one for the circumstances.
Make yourself a kind of silence, don't say what you think.
If you decide I shall say what I please know you are putting
your loved ones at risk. Listen to the hinges, listen hard. If you care to know
what I think, I think they are robbing us blind and we want to stay
blind. Speechless too, even our loved ones will testify against us.